India, Rants
Comments 38

The Romance of India, and What It’s Like to Return After 6 Years Abroad.

One year ago, on this day, I packed my life in Singapore and boarded a flight back home to India. Like a hopeless romantic finally uniting with her first love, my head filled with starry-eyed dreams. I dreamt about magical places I could travel to within my own country. I thought about the many causes I could make a difference to. I imagined proving the notions of most Indians who choose not to live in India, wrong. I swore by John F. Kennedy’s words, ask not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country.

In this one year, I have come a long way since my dreamy self boarded that flight. I developed a love-hate relationship with Delhi, travelled to countless small villages & towns, marvelling at the natural beauty India is adorned with, and let the stark reality of social issues in India dawn on me. In my first few months, I lived with purpose, preaching the spectrum between optimism and idealism to everyone I knew, including myself. I refused to accept that anything was impossible to change, especially mindsets. I tried to fight head on the inefficiencies in the ‘system’. Sometimes I gave up, but mostly I escaped into the wilderness that can be found beyond any Indian city. I rejuvenated amid the magnificence of the Himalayas and the Shivaliks. I rejoiced in the warmth of the people I met on the countryside. I gathered myself on the shores of the Arabian Sea.

Diu, India beaches, Arabian Sea

Letting my hair down by the Arabian Sea in Diu.

I didn’t know then, that in the coming months, I would slowly trash my conviction and accept that I can’t be the change I want to see in this country, the country I loved to bits. I slowly started to understand that it is not easy to live in a country plagued by poverty and homelessness, after experiencing life in a better part of the world. How do you go about your life – eat at a fancy restaurant, spend a fortune on a fancy hotel, shop at a mall, do anything really – when there is someone who, by mere fate, is sleeping on the streets and begging for his next meal? This maybe exactly how a westerner feels in India, and it makes me wonder how so many of us Indians can suppress, or even eliminate, the contradiction of our everyday lives. There are many ways to look at it, say that everyone’s trying to make the best of their lives with what they have. Or that our only responsibility is to be a law abiding, tax-paying citizen. Or worse still, that the government and everything else under the sun is to blame. Or simply that this is how it is, and what can anyone do. India is struggling with a billion other issues to which the same questions & arguments apply. How can one, with any basic human tenets, accept it and live with it, I don’t know. How can one get out there and change it, I don’t know either.

I always thought I was one of those people who could adapt to life under any circumstances, water or no water, cleanliness or no cleanliness, comfort or no comfort. If one year in India of doing what I do has taught me anything about myself, it is that I am not one of those people. With a sinking self-esteem, I confess that I want and need my urban comforts. To those who can do without them, I say kudos, especially those who come to India after growing up in the west, and live a bare minimum life to follow their heart’s conviction.

Diu, India beaches, Arabian Sea

The road that leads somewhere, hopefully!

Time & again in this one year, I’ve floated the idea of leaving Delhi, and leaving India, to live in another part of the world. Maybe it’s the restless wanderer in me that craves change. Maybe it’s because no logic justifies living in a city / country where I instinctively grab my pepper spray after dark. I know that running away is not the answer. But I don’t know what is.

***

38 Comments

  1. I understand your dilemma. I loved my trip to India to attend the wedding of our lovely friends. Everybody we met was delightful, friendly, inquisitive and happy to have us at their celebration. But, India made me feel so guilty….how could I just fly home and resume my life of (relative) luxury, while so many people had such dreadful lives….and how could they be so nice to us when some of them had so little???? It is a very confronting country for people who have affluent lives. I came home and sponsored a little girl in India…such a small thing, but hopefully better than nothing.

    Like

    • I’m glad you did that, Debra. Living in India, so many of us learn to turn a blind eye to everything that goes on beyond our lives. I don’t know what’s more alarming, our inequality or our apathy.

      Like

  2. Reshmy Pillai says

    Very true, the contrast is appaling. Just a mumbai local ride will let you glimpse that, you really don’t need to travel much but again that’s what this country is known for – its contrasts in everything! (Not that people living in miserable conditions is a happy thing to have.) Its been the story of this land always – we have the grandest opulance called Taj but look at the families that built it (they live close by in a gully where most of us will not venture into, losing there eyesight every young owing to the minute work they do!)

    Like

    • Somehow the contrast in Bombay is evident much more in Delhi. A friend of mine just recently made an observation that Bombay is probably the only place where morning walkers / joggers don’t look towards the sea, because that’s where the fishermen slums are. That’s our answer, if you don’t acknowledge it, it doesn’t exist.

      Like

  3. I feel every word of what you say in this one shivya! This dilemma is something I fight with everyday too. My dad and sis live in the US and its so tempting to pack one’s bags and move to a country where getting clean drinking water is not a luxury! 10 years back I had some hope that things will change for the better. But now with a sinking feeling I am realizing that may not be so. Not in my lifetime at least. Feels terrible

    Like

    • @justanotherwakeupcall …i can understand your pain but I am still hopeful we can bring that much needed change , we need to keep the spirits high and work together with the conviction that someday we will breathe in India we always dream about.

      Like

    • It does, especially considering that we technically ‘celebrate’ our freedom today. Sigh. But kudos to you for not taking that easier route of packing your bags & leaving. I think I’ll give in to that temptation sooner than later.

      Like

  4. raji says

    Shivya,
    U hv been an inspiration so far. I hope this is one passing bout of depression/pessimism. And that u will figure out your way out of it.
    I wud love to live like u – travel, explore, meet new people, learn n grow with every experience…
    U r a brave girl. I m double ur age n still ispired by u.
    Wud b nice to meet u. I m on gurgaon.
    All the best.

    Like

  5. It is so refreshing to see someone being so honest! I used to get bogged down by everything earlier (and still do!). The garbage on the road, the streetlights on at 11 am, the contrast between my ‘cushioned’ life as compared to those who make up the majority of India, the corruption (oh I’m sure you could add to the list). I’d complain I couldn’t change anything, this is how it IS. And then a friend told me it’s better to take baby steps than trying to change everything all at once. And that is something I live by now. At least the milk man next door has stopped using plastic bags. And look at you, through India Untravelled, you’re doing your bit. Small, yes, but definitely not insignificant.

    I think you don’t ‘belong’ to a country. A country’s essence contributes to yours. So no matter how far my travels have taken me, and however bright the colours there may be, India pulls me back each time.

    I’m really humbled to read this post Shivya. As long as India has people like you, we have hope 🙂 Chin up!

    Like

    • You said it, Chandi.

      “I think you don’t ‘belong’ to a country. A country’s essence contributes to yours. So no matter how far my travels have taken me, and however bright the colours there may be, India pulls me back each time.” I think I shall find it true for myself even if I choose to move away for a while.

      And you’re right. We’ve got to do the little things we can. It’s true for everything out there in the world.

      Like

  6. I totally understand your feelings.I personally feel that I can put up with bad roads,garbage etc..though my blood boils when I see them.But the greatest problem for me in India,is the issue of safety for women.In event of a crime,the female is judged and even ‘blamed’ for the crime.I just want to walk in the streets and feel I am a person,and not get reminded every instant that I am a female.

    Like

  7. Hi shivya,
    I have been reading your blogs.. loved it lot.But reading this one- i really want to say that–You must linger on your passion and belief….. journey always has ups and downs.. 🙂
    I am sure You have endless places to explore in india.

    Sanjeev

    Like

    • I do have endless places to explore in India, even a lifetime might not be enough to go everywhere! But then the rest of the world awaits too. Classic dilemma :p

      Like

  8. A few days down the line, I will be echoing your exact same sentiments. I moved back to India from the U.S utterly because I wanted to and not because of any other factor. WIth much patriotism and idealism on the endless possibilities that seemed to be, everything seemed to be gung-ho from the other side. A few months down the line, although the optimism remains, the stark disparities and the problems that ail even day today life are cutting into the initial enthusiasm and stubborn belief that things will improve. I know I am happier here, but the mind wanders back to thinking, did I make a mistake?Did I really want to move to a country where roads are horrible, infrastructure is laughable, basic manners are missing and where there is such a general apathy towards everything? If you do head back, I ld totally understand and not lament the loss of one more brain like I might have done just a year back! And besides, I am sure the wanderer in you won’t let you stay in one place for more than a period of time! Good luck with where ever destiny takes you!

    Like

    • Thanks Richa, in a strange way, it helps to know that I’m not the only feeling less optimistic now more than ever. I hope it’s a passing phase, and I hope you don’t get to where I am anytime soon. I think it’s to do with the inflated expectations I had, the thought that India is the greatest country in the world, which in some ways it is and in many ways it is not.

      Like

  9. I completely relate to what you are saying. It has been 1.5 years since I came back from Manchester but there isn’t a single day when I do not think of going back. I feel like Frodo who found the Shire completely alien after he returned from his adventures. 🙂

    Like

  10. Abhinav Arora says

    The glass is half full, or did someone drink your half glass?
    If any country has better infrastructure or better mannerism or higher safety for lives, don’t they have higher tax rates, colour discrimination, or any morality? Every country has it’s characteristic flaws, nowhere it’s is as perfect as the myriad of culturally rich country we call home.

    Like

    • Abhinav Arora says

      I do sincerely respect your travel endeavours, and look up to your experiences.

      Like

    • Higher safety is a myth, just see the random senseless trigger happy guys …
      corruption, lies, scandals and brainwashing/misleading citizens happens in all countries, India is much better … it still has a relatively independent press … something missing even in the most desirable developed countries .. 🙂

      Like

  11. People in the US and UK and for that matter all of rich Europe, might have had the same feelings say 150 years ago. There was crime and corruption, oligarchies and nepotism just like we have in India..but some good people made some good institutions and things have changed in those countries…Our generation would probably be the one which can usher in and see that very change occur in our country. So rather than being pessimistic we should think of ways to be good citizens, help our countrymen, save resources and help build a country we would be proud of giving away to our posterity. Jai Hind!

    Like

  12. This is a well-written post. I can feel the sincerity and the hope in your words. I’ve been wanting to visit India since the stories I’ve heard from Flipnomad makes me curious. It is nice to hear from your point of view. I know that wherever you may go, your heart is still with India. Wish you luck and happiness on your upcoming travels! ❤

    Like

  13. Shivya, there are bound to be times when this country gets you down, especially when the contrasts are all around and our options are limited and often frustrating. But I think it takes real grit to stick with it and try our level best to change things around us. We cannot of course change the entire country or improve everybody’s lives, but look at the possibilities to do that here! Even if you reach out to only a few people and change their lives, you make such a difference! Which other country can afford you that?

    You have the opportunity to be a change-maker with your rural travel initiatives that can impact so many lives. Perhaps its time to chin up and take charge? YOU certainly can be the change you want to see around you!

    Like

  14. Cathleen Howard says

    My heart is wth you in this dilemma. Our nationalities are different and we are experiencing different cultures (I am US and living in Mexico), but the common goal is to discover who we really are and how do we fit into the rest of the world.

    Like

  15. I have been reading (a lot on) your blog since yesterday night. And am feeling very thankful for Sapna’s blog, ‘Just another wake-up call’ for giving a link to yours in her recent post.

    You are only 24 but an inspiration, Shivya. Who says age has anything to do with inspiring people? You have a new fan in me now, whether you decide to stay or not : )

    Good luck and keep up this blog wherever you go!

    Like

  16. Pingback: Why The World Should End on December 21st, 2012. | The Shooting Star

I'd love to hear your thoughts and feedback.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s